Sunday, January 08, 2012
La Que No Podía Amar #5 Friday 1/7/12 I Need A New Attitude: In Which RoHellio Earns Bonus Points For Most Pitiful Cripple of the Year And Then Immediately Loses Them for Being Biggest Brute of the Year.
Labels: no-podia
Yup! Rogelio's got a lot of atoning to do to bring us 2012 viewers along to think of him as a good supportive guy to a modern woman like nurse/master filer Ana Paula. These gothic tales that take place on lonely estates and involve brutes with hearts of gold and naive young women who heal their wounds aren't easy to translate to today's times.
On the other hand, JS is doing a great job in the role and it's fun to watch while keeping score.
This story is really growing on me. Rogellio is gorgeous sometimes and frightful sometimes, but always more interesting than any of the other men in the story.
I like that Cinthia character, even if she is always hot to trot.
The best thing is all you recappers. I would never have kept watching without the recaps.
There has been a lot of talk of how to use CC's to help you learn Spanish. One of the recappers, I forget who, suggested watching first with the Spanish CCs and then watch with no CCs. Whoever suggested it, it is really good advice.
He lost MAJOR points with me when he first refused to let Margarito learn to read and write and said it was useless, and then whipped Bruno bloody. It reminded me of a slave owner/master, and that is not an image that holds any romanticism for me. As I watched him whip Bruno and saw the hate in Bruno's eyes, I thought that Ro-Hell deserves any revenge Bruno may be plotting. You do not aggressively strip a man of his dignity/humanity like that and not expect repercussions. Rogelio has it coming to him. Do what you need to do Bruno. (This does not mean that I like Bruno. I just now understand any need for revenge he might have.)
I am especially grateful since my English CCs only seemed to be working on the conversations I could understand. Never for the mumbled or fast ones. *grumble grumble* Lo and behold, they really were talking about cake. I was all "huh?, did I hear that right?" Apparently I did.
I did not like Bruno's beating at all. But then he was really so tender with Ana Pau while she slept and his episode ending challenge also seemed to be light-hearted. Oh-hell is a complex character. I find myself feeling guilty for liking him because he really is so brutal.
The Ana Bertha Espin is playing Tia mentiRosa makes it hard for me to dislike her in the way I dislike the traditional villians. It's more like "wow, she's a piece of work." Vainessa on the other hand is someone I truly dislike. Very selfish and all about herself. I find it difficult to believe she really loves Oh-Hell. I think she just likes his money and power.
I can't remember who mentioned it, but Julian Gil does look skeletal.
Love how Ana Paula keeps standing up to Ro-hell. I am glad she insisted that Margarito needs an education. She treats him like her little brother.
That Vinessa, very selfish, why would she think Ro-hell would take her back? I like her dad though, he seems like a good guy.
Tia MeniRosa what a piece of work. Gus may as well forget about it, unless he runs into Ana Paula again.
A few years ago I made this comment at Telenovela World: I tuned in to watch the first episode of Te Sigo Amando and I couldn't get past the image of the protagonista being whipped in the entrada. So I skipped that one. This is a remake and I can't get behind a man who is blasting women back to the 10th century. So I hope this improves or I'll be watching something else.
I just cked the list of characters, Esteban is Marco Mendez, Vanesa must be loca. In the galán rating, I would give him 2nd place after JS.
Rogelio's dimples (when he smiles) AP,s dimples, guess all the kids will be dimpled.
Those were the eyes of the devil Bruno had, surprised they weren't red.
-----
ISTA, Vario!! I am wondering about Vainessa. Honestly I wonder if she is just thinking "the grass...er...money is always greener." (Complete conjecture. I have not seen past Friday's episode.) I am very much looking forward to getting a peek at her marriage since she is soooo miserable.
In defense of the indefensible Rogelio, he did point out to Cinthia that if she had shown any aptitude for anything so far, she would have found a interest around the hacienda and be running part of the business by now. So I think part of it him making fun of her sudden college ambitions was him calling her out on her lack of initiative up until now.
I don't mind that Rogelio is a brute - it's essential to the story. Although I really don't understand how these grown men can't simply run away from Rogelio when he goes after them with his whip. And I don't quite see how a riding crop can begin to tear a shirt, but then I've never used one. It's definitely beanie time on this aspect of the story.
Again, fab expressions on JS's face as he continues to deliver an amazing performance. Loved the challenge. Some important lessons for naive Ana Paula coming up - you don't bet with someone about changing them! Dumb, dumb, dumb! Rogelio sure looked excited about the idea though - LOL!
Audrey
That Tia Mentirosa falls into the same category as Vanesa. So incredibly selfish and everything is about how they can benefit from others. Tia is futher down the road of awful at this point...
jb
I think we now have two permanent nicknames: Tia MentiRosie and Vainessa. I'm definitely using both of those. And those women are two of a kind.
Sin-thia definitely didn't show a whole lot of initiative. What was she doing with herself before Rogelio's accident, flirting or doing the horizontal tango with his friends? She's just looking to escape now. I doubt that she has the self-discipline to go to college; she's just looking for a fertile hunting ground.
Mexico's current literacy rate is 93.4%. Rogelio needs to look at this. Whoever Margarito is, he needs to learn to read, write, and do math. And I'm guessing that Rogelio currently thinks that any attention Ana Paula gives to him is equal to what she takes away from himself.
I had seen this episode before (sans CCs), but when it came on, I was having computer problems and was distracted, and therefore didn't really pay attention to the CCs. I really appreciated some of the gaps you filled!
Audrey wrote: Although I really don't understand how these grown men can't simply run away from Rogelio when he goes after them with his whip. And I don't quite see how a riding crop can begin to tear a shirt, but then I've never used one. It's definitely beanie time on this aspect of the story.
YES, THIS.
When I first saw this scene I was really shocked and disturbed (like the rest of you) but kept on because the story had me hooked and Jorge Salinas is awesome. But also, I was simply confused—how is it that able-bodied men who are all younger than Rogelio just take this kind of abuse. You've got a man in a wheelchair who is holding the whip/crop in one hand and wheeling himself around in the other hand—he can't really maneuver that well doing that—can't these guys evade at least some of this damage that Rohell is inflicting? Okay, maybe the worker-men in the first episode felt that they "had" to take it because of their financial/social position, but Bruno is more of a social equal, and has other opportunities and options. And also (this is me speculating about Ro-hell, no spoilers) I think that it wouldn't make that much difference to Ro-hell if Bruno avoided some of the blows. I think that Rohell is on his little freakout and after a certain point it's over and then that's it. So I just don't get it.
With that said, it was appalling, and you have to keep your beanie tightly afixed for a lot of reasons during that scene. You have to have faith that there is something redeemable about Ro-hell despite him having severe anger management issues, and you have to believe that a wheelchair-bound man with a riding crop in one hand can still run down a younger, able-bodied man and do that much damage. WHAT EVER. Beanie time, beanie time! LOL
As I've said before, if Rohell were a real person I'd want nothing to do with him, but since this is novelaland, we have the luxury of waiting around to see if he can clean up his act.
I also agree that even though I am a Rogelio fangirl, that there are times like this that my sympathy-meter is at ZERO for any pain he may suffer. Oh Rogelio, Rogelio, how I love you, you huge jerkwad!
That he so quickly "allowed" Margarito to be educated later on seems to bear this out. He never meant it, he was just seeing how far he could push it because he's a jerkwad. If there's an extra buttheaded way to do something, you can bet that Rohell will choose to do it that way.
But also I think he's starting to realize that maybe he'd like to get AP's approval, which is why he was more warm and cuddly at the end. We'll see how long that lasts! LOL.
Although he did roll across that field pretty fast to get to AP.
Polishing my beanie now.
1) The kid hadn't lived so LONG with him already with NO education. It's not like he's a 5 year old just at the age to learn.
2) He hadn't belittled the kid right to his face, and hadn't been doing so already for a long time. He is a child abuser (yes, verbal abuse counts), pure and simple. And that kid is jumpy and has low self esteem as a result.
He also calls the kid Amargo (bitter). It's a good thing AP came into his life, because Ro-Hell seemed determined to break this kids spirit. Not forgiveable.
As for whipping grown men, it seems to me that Ro-Hell gets off on making these grown men financially indebted to him-- financially slavery. And once he has them, he likes to show them that he owns them body and sould and so whipping them is his right. That's just sick and twisted.
I love JS, he can do wrong as far as I am concerned. There is no one out there that can do a love scene like he does. No wonder Vainessa is scratching at his door again.
I do not like Bruno. For those that watched CME, just substitute Augie for Bruno! I am going to need one of Emilia's beanies for this TN. If Bruno didn't want to be at end of El Jefe's whip, why didn't he move out of the way. Even I could have taken it away from him or moved out of the way. Is our Bruno into in a little S&M?
I haven't decided about AP, but at least she is smiling.
Rosemary
And then the look on Rohellio's face when later he realized he had caused the accident himself -- goodness. I have no idea what's going to happen, but my guess is some day the tables will get turned on Rohellio with that riding crop.
I'm not worked up about Rohellio pushing Sin-thia around because she's perfectly capable of fighting back against him. He may not know it's 2012, but she does. She is no withering vine. Sin-thia could simple enroll, if that's what she really wants to do, and send him the bill after the fact. She's using her tenacity to get around his "no fraternizing with the help" rule just fine.
I want to point out one thing that should be taken into account with this novela. The setting is (intentionally) in Chiapas. If there's one state that is behind the rest is this one. And these characteres live close to a small town where people mostly live out of the work of the hacienda. That's the kind of power Rogelio has.
If anyone is intereste, here are some facts about the state that would help clarify the environment in which we are submerged in this story.
Rogelio's backwardness, thus, is not surprising to me, even if we are in 2012. His attitude with Margarito and Cinthia and everyone is not something that I find out of touch with reality. However, that does not mean it is something that should be forgiven. In fact, it is because I'm familiar with that sort of thinking that he upsets me even more and it makes it harder to simpathize with him. Even if, and also because, Jorge Salinas is doing such a fabulous job with the role.
However, I do find those double dimple scenes with Ana Paula to be pretty charming.
Jarocha
Chiapas is one of the places I have thought about going in Mexico. I was in Guanajuato & loved it but want to go someplace different. There were some people from Chiapas on one of my tours & they said how beautiful it is. What is your opinion? I'm not that interested in beach, since I look at water every day, & I don't want gringoland either.
Vivi: LOL! it appears so.
Jarocha
I've added a new feature to my TN beanie--a special "dimple defense" strap that can be tightened. It allows me to ignore Rohell's barbaric attitude and treatment of others due his dimples and to ignore Ana Paula's excessive sweetness and optimism due to her dimples.
I'm waiting for a scene where they face each other, insert the tips of their index fingers in each other's dimples, then rotate the finger tips as they say "coochie coochie coo."
Even the dimple defense can't allow for the bloody beating of Bruno. And I don't even like Bruno, but that's too much. Maybe it's a measure of how much Rohell has to change.
Anonymous, I did have the very same problem you did with the English CCs. They're useful, but they also interfere with my Spanish comprehension.
Jarocha, thanks for that useful background on Chiapas. It does explain a lot. Having only a few large landowners explains part of Rohell's "lord of the manor" snotty attitude. All those water resources also tell us why it's a good thing to be a hydraulic engineer.
Rohell has really taken advantage of his position to extend his personal pity party to entire area. Too bad he's made life so hard for everyone else.
Final question--I know the cattle are important, but why do they let them wander across the front yard of the hacienda?
La Paloma
And wouldn't Margarito HAVE to be in school? I haven't looked up the link that Jarocha put up yet, but I'll assume the answer is that Rogelio controls everything and he's a total butthead. Now that Bruno isn't as leering as he was at first, he's growing on me and I hope he gets some revenge on Ro-Hell. This guy might have to cure cancer or something big to get my forgiveness, cute or not.
Side note, Jarocha- How's the safety in San Cristobal and Chiapas in general? I was in Cuernavaca in 1994 for 2 weeks over Xmas break, and when the problems broke out in Chiapas, parents were calling the school all panicked. Never mind that these cities are a few hours away. I assume it's different now, but curious to know from a more local viewpoint since even in SoCal we mostly hear the worst.
Kelly
Word ref: Woryand. Parents did too much woryand.
Maybe the first thing AP should do is take that whip and hide it. Rog also needs to get rid of the old way of thinking of a woman cooking and cleaning. Times are different now.
On the other hand, AP may be in over her head trying to change Rog when he's so stuck in his ways. This novela reminds me so much of Jane Eyre in that regard.
=======
Jarocha, that was a most enlightening bit of information on Chiappas. It does explain a great deal about the setting and the characters' motivations and attitudes.
========
I have problems with my Spanish CC's. I didn't think to switch to CC3 for English. If I missed anything in the dialog it was probably a combination of missing words and whole sentences at times when JS and AP were racing through their dialog. Sorry about that. : ? /
=========
This is indeed a "gothic tale", Traveling Lady.
For those of you who remember the earlier versions of this fairytale, I believe I read that this storyline has been altered in places (per three-frito rules) so don't go around thinking you know what's going to happen. I just pray it isn't the ridiculous botch-job CS2009 turned out to be--riveting as it was.
More later.
However, I will say that when I first watched this, the attention and time spent on establishing Rohellio's and Ana's relationship and "chemistry" right from the start (like we have seen this first week) put me and a lot of other fangirls in the Rohellio/Ana camp.
In "Teresa," we had Teresa starting out with her "true love" Doctor Hottie (Mariano) but ending up with Professor Hottie (Arturo). She lost her virginity to Mariano and everything, yet I think I knew from the start that she'd end up with Professor Hottie. Just the way the show was written and presented made that obvious to me, though I don't think everyone viewed the storyline the way I did.
There's no telling after the first week who AP will end up at the end of the novela (and the show hasn't even finished filming in Mexico, I don't think). But I think in the upcoming weeks we'll get a better idea of who will be our favorite (or more likely) candidate for Ana Paula's affections in the end.
I'll be looking forward to the conversations in the weeks to come as we see how things develop!
In Querida Enemiga, the tn we have referenced with Chef Hawt (Jorge Arevena), the protagonist starts out with her true love played by Gabriel Soto, and all the promos, intros, everyting had the two of them together. But Chef Hawt becomes a rival for her heart and in the end she ends up marrying and staying with him. But they kept the audience guessing for a long time who she would choose. For a long time most assumed she end up with her first love in the end. But I think the audience liked her more mature 2nd love better.
I don't care if Cinthia's sudden desire for a college education is questionable or not. She should be allowed to "escape" the hacienda and live her life. Rogelio also is not in position to make an assesment that his sister does not have the aptitude for business or else she would have been working in some capacity in the hacienda. Even if Cinthia probably did have the business aptitude, I think Rogelio would have prevented that in order to consolidate his power and authority in the hacienda. For all intents and purposes, he is the king and lord over all that matters in that part of their universe. No way would he want to share that wih anyone. Even his sister. It would also make him terribly insecure especially now since he has been crippled. i'm not excusing his behavior but rationalizing his motives for "oprressing" people like Cinthia and Bruno et al.
I'm really intrigued by the 2 beautiful young ladies Cinthia and Ana Paula. Those 2 are my favorites right now and not just because of their looks.
Ibarramedia
---------------------------------
/offtopic, now back to the episode
The fourth one ended with a bang. I was really impressed with Jorge's acting, those were some very intense scenes. What a comeback for him, after several years of sitting on the bench. I thought his eyeballs will pop out when he falls down. Love his voice, he's a great screamer and whiner and he can do that soft voice too. I hope though that he will quit smoking once and for all, after he was with one foot in the graveyard last year because of a severe pulmonary thrombosis. 2-3 months ago he was hospitalized three times and he even got married despite having been released from hospital only a couple of days before the event. He's a very stubborn man; he said he promised to get married on that date and he did, despite the fact that she wanted to postpone it for his sake.
Just like Jorge, Rogelio is an incredibly stubborn man too - and with a big ego. He just wouldn't admit that he needs help or that he was wrong. I can imagine how frustrating it is to be trapped in a wheelchair, unable to do normal activities, but you can either try living like a normal human being or give up the fight and become a grumpy handsome dimpled man like Rogelio. He was trying to show to AP that he doesn't need any help to get back on the wheelchair, but he was just in denial and he hated the fact that she was right. Let's say I understand his attitude towards AP in the beginning of the episode, because he was riveted and angered by Vanesa and he's not the type to cool off in 3 minutes. But AP seems to have a stubbornness of her own and shows commitment.
Gus - sorry dude, I still hate you. You're just too 'Ken-dolly' for me. And probably Aunt Rosy does have a suspicion that Gus is Miguel's boss, but she doesn't want to ask, because if Miguel tells her his name and if this issue will ever come up in a conversation with Ana Paula and Miguel and AP would ask her auntie why didn't she tell her that Miguel and Gus knew each other, she wouldn't know what to say. It might be a preventive measure to come clean if it will ever be the case. Or maybe she's just...clueless?
Ana Paula is starting to grow on him. At first, while he said that he would like to tame her, it seems that in fact, he wants her to tame him. The moment she stood up to him, he started to admire her and now, it looks as though this admiration could go even further. Now the question is if all this will develop into a real love or if it's just an illusion, because she reminds him of his former lover, who, by the way, did she actually think that he would forgive her so easily? I mean time heals the wounds only if the hurt one allows it to. I understand that she was young and thoughtless, but seriously, it took her 7 years to realize it and to apologize? Glad that Rogelio burned her picture, it's time now to move on.
Loved the moments when Rog is taking care of AP after the fall, he looked so concerned. He should go to Anger Management Therapies, because what he did to Bruno was very cruel. It was all AP's fault and Rogelio's - AP because she wanted to go faster, leaving Bruno behind and Rogelio because of course he fired the gun. Still, even though she was mumbling in her sleep saying that he's a bad man, he didn't make that angry face and leave, but he stayed there and hold her hand. That was cute! Then, his willingness to change and to even let Margaro read, well, what can I say, the game is on!
So far I have a love-hate relationship with Rogelio, but I'm glad that the order is in fact hate-love, since he always redeems himself in one way or the other. He does something awfully unpleasant, but then he turns into a sweet and caring guy, who even has remorse (and right so!) for what happened to AP. Somehow, the endings of the episodes always find me on the Rogelio bandwagon. I believe he is capable of loving someone, but he must do something about that rage of his. It's not enough for him to love - he must make others love him too. Not only other characters, but also the audience. I do love him already, but I'll admit it's not for the right reasons, but rather because I love his type of character; in real life I would probably cross the street if I would see him coming towards me.
There's still hope though that he will change for good, although changes don't happen overnight.
PS: Sorry for writing a testament, but I can't help it :(. I wasn't even allowed to write the entire comment in 1 post, because it was too long lol.
Here are some more thoughts regarding Rohell (again no spoilers, I thought this when I first saw this episode). Now granted, I first saw this sans CCs, and as I keep saying, my comprehension of spoken Spanish is not "there" yet, so I missed some of Rohell's more arrogant/appalling comments the first time around. But even so, I'm still a Rohell fangirl, in part because Jorge Salinas=AWESOME and because I have a good beanie! LOL. And also because Rohell is a nuanced character that gets under your skin after a while.
I have appalling taste in literature and have read too many Harlequin romances in my day. So I viewed some of his behavior in episode 5 based on the Harlequin model.
Here goes: When he and Paula spent that "quality time" in his office where she was helping him out, I think his neanderthal brain started to comprehend that this was not a girl he necessarily wanted to "domesticar" (tame) like he said a few episodes ago. He now wants her to like him and approve of him. He also sees her as being worth more than a hundred Vainessas, which is why, right after she left the office, he goes and burns Vainessa's photo. And why he "allows" Margarito to be educated and why he's in a better mood and trying to act good-natured.
I think we all know he's still got a ways to go, but that's how I interpreted the timeline of Friday's episode. We'll see how it pans out in the episodes to come.
Mar Contreras, aka Vanesa Galván, played Lucía in "Teresa" and wore freely her naturally curly hair there. She had to have it straight for this role.
Jarochar
I think I'll go looking for a Quetzal in Cost Rica one of these days. :). I don't think it will require a multi-day jungle trek.
Audrey
Not that I take telenovelas that seriously anyway! :)
Audrey
Jarocha, thanks so much for the Chiapas info.
Also, don't forget that the reason why he goes all bananas is that when he sees her falling down, he practically sees himself falling down from the horse and for a moment, he was afraid that his favorite nurse might end up in a wheelchair just like him. That's what scared him more than anything, the horrible thought that she won't be able to walk again. He completely overreacts, no excuse to the hard beating of Bruno, Rog should have beaten himself, but he just didn't get used to seeing someone riding a horse while he can't do it anymore and especially falling from it.
Sorry if I'm tiring :(, I'll try to limit my thoughts in a single comment.
Your comments bring up something I was thinking of before—the reason why Rogelio might have freaked out extra big time over this—his understandable fear that Ana Paula could end up in a wheelchair like him. Was his freakout justified? Was the drawing of blood justified? Of course not. Nor does it explain the other jerkwaddery things he does all the time. But I think it does help explain some of why he melted down THIS time.
When I first told one of my sisters (who is now following this show, despite not knowing any Spanish) about this show, and something about this scene, she exclaimed, "Just like Mr. Thornton!" Mr Thornton is the hero of a classic BBC drama "North & South" (2004, based on the Elizabeth Gaskell novel). In this clip (it's about a minute into the video, right after the Pride and Prejudice scene) we see Mr. Thornton go after an employee in a brutal way.
The explanation for Mr. Thornton's freakout is that he'd seen entire cottom mills burn down (and kill all the workers inside) in a short amount of time, due to a little flame that goes awry. So when he catches a worker smoking, he freaks out and beats him black and blue.
Now Mr. Thornton is a far nicer person than Rohell, but still, Rohell's freakout reminded me just a little bit of Mr. Thornton's. Not that beating someone is excusable in either case (as the heroine of "North and South" tells Mr. Thornton later).
I don't know what to think of Rogelio but must agree that redemption lies ahead. I can't help but fawn over Jorge once more, he exudes sheer animal magnatism.
Sara, so Marco is Vanessa's hub? she is obviously unbalanced if she is considering leaving him. A handsome hunk to be sure.
Jardinera, looking forward to all of your future recaps. This is going to be a good one!
Diana
========
Urban: ITA about Sinthia. Playing with Bruno's affections, perhaps? She seems as much a cynic as her brother after what Vainessssa did to the both of them.
=============
ViviDC: Revenge definitely would be my guess and Bruno would be justified after the beating he took. I don't see anything good in the end for him happening. May be he'll be a sacrificial lamb. He's just too much of a wimp.
=============
Madeleine/Karen: I'm hoping for AP to grab that whip out of his hands one day and use it on him! Give him a taste of his own medicine.
========
Cathyx: if you want to see the episodio it should be available on dailymotion.com or this link
http://www.novelasdetv.com/2011/08/la-que-no-podia-amar-capitulo-5.html
Yeah, the bit about wanting to test Ana Paula's cake baking skills after she proved a wiz at filing was really cute.
Why hasn't Cinthia just run away to start her own life? Two reasons: money and status. Plus she'd have to run pretty far to get out of Rogelio's sphere of influence. She'd leave behind a sizable inheritance (half the hacienda), and so far you can tell her social status is quite important to her. It's also much more difficult to start from ground zero in MX versus the US, and being female makes it worse. She really is trapped. She is dependent on her brother's support for whatever path she takes.
Audrey
Ibarramedia
Sue455, I also quit watching Te Sigo Amando after only watching 2 episodes for the very same reason you described. I'm a fan of Sergio Goyri but that was just too much for me.
La Paloma,
"I know the cattle are important, but why do they let them wander across the front yard of the hacienda?"
I thought that was so funny, especially since Rogelio is in a wheelchair because of a stampede. The gardener must be thrilled.
When my daughter and her family were evacuated from their home in Magnolia last summer because of the fires we had her 3 horses grazing in our front yard for a week. Rafael and his crew were not thrilled.
Carlos
Kelly
<< Home
© Caray, Caray! 2006-2022. Duplication of this material for use on any other site is strictly prohibited.