Tuesday, June 26, 2018
Por Amar Sin Ley, 6/26/18 Chapter 84 Martes: Guilt
- “Show me how you used it,” said Carlos after he handed the pen to Octavio.
“I don't remember; it happened so fast. He was very violent,” Octavio said as he fumbled with the pen.
“Show me how much force you used.”
Octavio stood up and picked the pen up from the table.
“I saw the knife and took it. Daniel was on the point of saying –”
“To you?”
Octavio got Carlos to stand up to get into position.
“He started to leave,” Octavio said. Carlos had his back to him. “I stopped him and stabbed.” He mimed a stab to the back. Carlos got him to sit down.
Carlos turned around and said, “Now, if I were Daniel, I'd have a wound right here,” He pointed to the area on the right side of his back, then looked at Octavio. “What then?”
“I turned him around to face me and stabbed him in the stomach. He fell to the floor and I stabbed him a few more times. That's all I remember.”
“And your daughter, Nuria? Where was she?”
“She, she was in her bedroom.”
“She didn't see what happened?” “No, no, no. It was all over when she came down.” He paused as Carlos watched him. “I know I did wrong. I was desperate. You don't know how I felt. You have to help me, Counselor. Please.” - Not every parent in the world would be willing to take the fall for his child. Octavio Guzman is one of those. But he did so without thinking that this would have consequences, starting with doing time for perjury.
- Juan walked into Roberto's office in a good mood and announced that Fernanda and he had reconciled. Roberto grinned and Leonardo said he was pleased for him. Juan said he told Fernanda he loved her and Roberto said he can't stop there. He has to show her that every day. Leonardo said “Above all, take care of her.”
“I will, Counselor.”
“Because it hurts very much to lose the one you love after all that time.” Leonardo looked back at Roberto.
“Yes, 100%” said Roberto. - Ricardo met with Alonso and told her things were improving. That he had never seen his children so anxious as when this happened. Alonso was willing to give him more time off but Ricardo said he needed to come back to work because of what happened to his client. Alonso has been informed about that by Alejandra and they spoke about the Benjamín problem. Ricardo offered his help. Alonso told him that his first priority was to protect the firm. He then updated Ricardo on the Durantes case.
- Carlos called Alejandra, who didn't return his call the night before. She told him she had had a difficult day. He told her that he knew why and that was the reason for his call. When he told her he had taken the case Alejandra told him that Octavio was not an innocent in this matter. She told him to give him a good defense as they all must but that he should not avoid prison for this. He understood that but said he needed her help in order to better understand this case. She was annoyed at this request but agreed to meet with him at his office.
- For once Carlos had a legitimate reason to want to meet with Alejandra. She really should invite Ricardo to the meeting since it appears that all of them have smelled a rat. However, Carlos seems to have also forgotten that his office is not a safe place. In fact, is anyplace safe from El Ciego?
- Olivia went to Leticia's office to ask if she knew how to find Benjamín, since she had to send the divorce petition. Leticia said she didn't know. She became bitchy when Olivia asked her to let him know she was looking for him in case he contacted her, then ended the conversation by taking something to the file room.
- The other Musketeers went to Ricardo's office to welcome him back. They talked about the Durantes case and then Gustavo mentioned that things between him and Isabel were steadily improving.
- Victoria and Olivia talked about Olivia's situation. Olivia didn't know what to do now that Leonardo seemed within reach. Victoria asked Olivia why she just doesn't take the opportunity to finally get Leonardo and she answered that it was because she was dating Alan. She had never been in that situation before.
Alan called at that moment to invite her to dine with him. She accepted. When she hung up she asked “What was I supposed to do?”
“Nothing. Until you know what you want, go with the flow.” - Alejandra arrived at Carlos' office and they sat down on the couch to talk. She told him that all Daniela had asked for was photos and updates on the child, nothing else. Daniela and Nuria agreed to the terms that had been set, then later Nuria failed to comply. Daniela came back to Vega for help because of that. There was no reason for her to die. Octavio needed to go to prison for this.
“I thought the same thing until I talked to him. That's why I have to talk to you.” He opened the file. “I'll explain the details to you but first here is the forensic report and his confession. I'd like to know what you think.” - Victoria went to Ricardo's office to discuss his case for being legally recognized as the father of Elena's children. They would need to go to court with this shortly. Ricardo said this might not be a good time for them to do this. She then asked whether he was thinking of getting back together with Elena. He said no, but he realized that the accident had a major impact on her. He didn't want to face another fight about the children now. Victoria understood. Ricardo said that the court date needed to happen because the man in the accident with Elena had drugs with him, which complicated the issues. She told him that if he decides to go ahead with this it would have to happen very soon. Any delay would make the process more difficult. He told her not to worry. He hoped that Elena would see reason during her recovery.
- Based on her past behavior it's far more likely that Elena will make herself appear like an angel during her recovery and the claws will be unsheathed thereafter.
- Carlos and Alejandra went to the crime scene. He looked at the location where the body was and at a nearby small table with a land-line phone, saying that Octavio had identified that spot as where the knife had been.He turned Alejandra around so her back was to him and put his hand on her shoulder. “He had her on the left and thus...” He made the stabbing motion. “Daniela was tall, almost the same height as Octavio. It would be logical if the wound were below the ribs and on the right side.”
“Why would a knife be here? This is impossible; it makes no logical sense. He couldn't explain where the knife came from, least of all why it was there.” He then mimed picking up the knife. “He picked up the knife. Pretend you are Daniela.”
Alejandra looked at the forensic report.
“But the wounds were lower and on the left side.”
“Of course. It's no coincidence. Alejandra, somebody is lying.”
“Also, the wounds weren't made with much force.”
“Yes. Octavio is a stocky man and strong.”
“This doesn't agree with what they're saying.”
“It doesn't. Alejandra, I'm sure they're lying to us.”
She turned around and took another look at the room. - Leticia arrived to visit Elena, telling her she looked like she was healing rapidly. Elena told her that Ricardo was very good to her. She said she realized she almost lost her children and her life and that she couldn't understand how she could have behaved so immaturely by trying to cut Ricardo out of their lives. Leticia told her that she seems to realize what is really important to her. Elena went on about how she took out her own issues on Ricardo and went to Carlos to make life difficult for him. She seemed to not understand why he was helping her after how she treated him.
- Alejandra continued reading the report, saying that one of the wounds was on the right side. Carlos repeated Octavio's words that the wounds were in the middle of the stomach. Alejandra read that there were multiple wounds woven together, not applied with a lot of force.
“No. no, no; he did this with feeling. It was a crime passionel.,” said Carlos.
“Yes. Listen to this. It says that the aggressor was a left-handed person because of the angle of the wounds.”
“When I handed the pen to Octavio he took it in his right hand.” Then Carlos remembered seeing Nuria sign the DIEF documents with her left hand. “But, Alejandra, Nuria is left-handed. Now I understand.”
“It was she, Carlos. She killed Daniela and Octavio is taking the fall to protect her.”
Carlos nodded and looked back at her in shock. - Leticia told Elena that things weren't going well for her because of Benjamín and the atmosphere in the office. She told her that she thought that her colleagues all saw her as an accomplice to his crimes. She felt lost and didn't know what to do. Elena told her to thin of herself and maybe leave the firm for somewhere else.
- Alejandra then came up with the way the crime played out by concluding that Nuria had been in the kitchen during the argument, took the knife, and came at Daniela from behind. Carlos said she was right and asked her how Nuria was when she saw her.
“She was nervous when she came down from her room. She looked normal; I didn't understand how she heard nothing. She got hysterical and then Octavio said he was responsible.”
“You know what? We should register the whole house as a crime scene. Somewhere in it is something that proves your theory.” - It looked like Carlos wanted to prolong the investigation. He could easily prove that there was a left-handed person in the Guzman family who was not cooperating with the agreement struck after a bitter case in court.
- Leonardo paid Ricardo a visit in his office to ask his advice about Olivia. He had been getting his hopes up while they were watching his kids. Ricardo told him to talk to her and fight for her if he had to. Leo talked about not being able to see her with Alan and Ricardo just told him to talk to Olivia and be completely honest with her.
- Carlos made a call about the house and said that if they didn't find anything in particular they would go with her theory as is. She told him to keep her informed and he promised he would do his best to promote her theory of the crime. He thanked her a little too profusely and kissed her hand. She looked rather grave.
- Leonardo left Ricardo's office and almost ran into Olivia. He did exactly the opposite of what Ricardo advised. He asked whether she was happy with Alan and when she did he said he was happy for her and to give him time to see her solely as a colleague and friend. She told him it was difficult for her, too. He then said he would just need time. Then he went on his way.
- I don't normally say this, but what the fuck? Did Leonardo feel guilty for wanting to be the man in Olivia's life? He may be the office nerd but isn't that better than a crook?
- Federico went into Elena's room, crying. He said there was something he had to tell her. He told her that the accident was his fault for calling his father. Elena told her that he was wrong, it was an accident. He wouldn't stop crying.
- Paula and her friends were tasting food for her birthday party. Their expressions changed when Alejandra arrived with Carlos behind her. Paula said she was planning an event but did not say what it was. Alejandra then told her that they figured out that Nuria was the killer. Paula was shocked that prejudice could go that far and Alejandra said that the worst was that Nuria had not thought about her child, who would now be without a family. “Yes, it's the children who always pay,” said Paula and her friends.
- Elena asked Federico what happened. He told her about discovering her friend taking drugs in the bathroom and shoving him into the wall when he realized Federico had seen him do it. He then grabbed Nati and they locked themselves in her room. They called their father. He came over, punched Miguel out, and took them to his apartment. Elena tried to assure him that he did the right thing. He protected his sister. He still wasn't reassured and Elena told him that this did not cause the accident. She finally admitted that the accident was due to her mistake and hugged him.
- And who should really take the blame for Federico's feelings of guilt? That may not have occurred to her yet.
- Carlos put down his wineglass and said goodnight. He thanked Alejandra again for helping him with this case, kissed her on the cheek, and left. Alicia commented on how good looking he was and they asked which of her guys she was inviting to her mother's birthday. She said “Neither of them.” The reason was that Ricardo was still taking care of his ex. She went up to her room because she needed to prepare for court the next day.
- Ricardo arrived at Elena's place where she was still trying to console Federico. He told him that the important thing was that his mother was alright and that he had done nothing wrong. Natalia came in and jumped on Ricardo's back. Elena said that the important thing was that they were together. She took Ricardo's hand. He laid down next to Federico and embraced Natalia. Elena looked very satisfied.
- Fernanda was at the Lopez house for dinner and Juan could not stop staring at her. He almost didn't hear his mother's questions about his day at the office. She finally got up and leaned over in between him and Fernanda to ask what was going on. He talked about Ricardo and his ex, then Alonso and the Durantes, telling her it was a difficult case because of an immunity issue that protected public officials from arrest. The intent was to protect them from political enemies but it also enabled them to commit corruption. Fernanda wanted to stop talking work and get on to other things.
- Leticia got an unwelcome visitor that evening when Benjamín showed up claiming he couldn't take it anymore. She made it clear she wanted nothing more to do with him but he didn't listen. He asked her if she would go to Carlos' firm with him and she told him he had more problems to deal with. She told him about Olivia seeking to serve him with divorce papers but he said he didn't care. She then told him that Alonso filed charges against him in order to protect the firm. That got to him and he became nasty.
- At a very different sort of watering hole from their usual Roberto advised Leonardo to relax. Leonardo could not stop thinking about Olivia. Roberto took out his cell phone to call some women and Leonardo told him not to. He was going to go home and think in the hopes that something would occur to him. Roberto kept up the pep talk until two women arrived and greeted him. They sat at the next table. Leonardo said he was leaving in half an hour. Roberto raised him, an hour and a half.
- Despite any efforts to oust him, Benjamín parked himself on Leticia's sofa and began downing tequila shots as he claimed Alonso was a traitor. Leticia said that Alonso did the right thing because of the money laundering and had the rest of the firm behind him on this. He ranted for a few minutes and Leticia finally stopped him and said that she hates that others suspect her of being his accomplice. She told him not to come anymore. He claimed that no evidence could be found on him. She told him to leave so she could think. She also told him to think about what he had to do. He tried to kiss her but she did not allow him to. He drank one more shot and still departed with a bad attitude.
- The two women in this bar turned out to be just as shallow as others from past encounters. The one seated with Leonardo was addicted to beauty treatments and social media and had nothing in common with him. Roberto dismissed that when Leonardo tried to explain this and told him he was too picky. He reminded him of the hour and a half. Leo told him that this was not the way to make him forget Olivia. Roberto suggested that they do a selfie. Leo allowed it.
- Leonardo must have had more to drink than usual. Surely he had never been so foolish as to allow this before.
- Alan took Olivia to an expensive restaurant and a waiter in black tie put a vase with a rose on their table. As Olivia talked about what a pretty gesture that was Alan went on about what a great woman and a great person she was, that he wanted to spend more time with her, and... took out a jewelry box containing something expensive.Guilt is often the most useless emotion. It occasionally leads to solutions but often it leads down a very negative path. Did Octavio Guzman hijack the murder of Daniela Seguro because he felt guilty for indoctrinating his daughter with his attitude? Will Ricardo's sense of guilt lead him back to a woman who used him for her ego? Carlos had no sense of guilt allowing Benjamín Acosta to take all the blame for the money-laundering. Olivia felt guilty about potentially cheating on Alan, to whom she is not even engaged. Nuria Guzman felt no guilt about the murder or allowing her father to take the fall. Elena has not admitted her own guilt about how her selfishness led to the accident. Until she does poor Federico will carry guilt too great for an adolescent boy. Leticia Jara is tired of looking guilty to her colleagues while Benjamín Acosta feels no guilt at all about any of his actions. The guilty are meant to pay and some will pay a very high price. Until next we meet Behind Mansion Walls, I'm Christopher Mason.
Labels: ley
Few people in this world feel completely free from guilt. This can be because of the teachings of childhood, a life-changing experience, or a feeling of inferiority. That makes it a powerful tool in the hands of the wrong people.
Glad to see Ric decided to go back to work. I was unmoved by Federico's crying. That boy is annoying and New Elena is not what she's cracked up to be. Since, as she told Leticia, Ric has been so good to her though she doesn't deserve it, why doesn't she bring up Ric adopting the kids?
Liked Paula turning her back to Carlos, ignoring him and going on with her party stuff. He's wisely stopped calling her "suegra."
So, Urban, here goes a double thank you for double duty. I so envy you all your screen shots and Christopher is the perfect host for this series.
As for me, I've really soured on PASL. I can't point to anything specific--maybe it's just too many cases. And right here at the end they bring Daniela back for one last gasp. But I complained about that earlier--they should have woven that thread throughout. It was an interesting dilemma.
I had to laugh, though, that while the police stand around guarding the yellow tape and the yellow labels on the floor, Carlos and Ale solve the case in 15 minutes or less. Triumphant, Carlos now has free reign over Ale to slobber his spit and his words. She's looking more disgusted with him, but WHEN OH WHEN is she going to tell him it's over and not that she has a lot to think about--and not that that will cool Carlos' fervor for reconquest.
Ric should take a lesson or two from Juan, now, if he really wants Ale back. At least he told Vicky (was it?) that there's no chance he and Elena will get back together.
Niecie--I so agree with you on Fede's "es mi culpa" scene. Annoying and totally inappropriate at age 13 (but what do I know). The scene would have been better played if he'd been in a blue funk for days and she finally got it out of him (but what do I know). At least he admitted knowing what Miguel was doing, while he didn't at the moment he called his father.
BUT...I admit it, this was my favorite line:
"I don't normally say this, but what the fuck? Did Leonardo feel guilty for wanting to be the man in Olivia's life? He may be the office nerd but isn't that better than a crook?"
Man, I could tell you were as annoyed as I was by that scene. Wanted to jump through the tv screen and punch wussy old Leonardo in the nose. And then the idiot goes out again with Roberto for another wasted, uncomfortable evening. Jeez. How many times has he protested and then done that very thing?! With the same results. Roberto is good at reeling in the vapid but beautiful gals, but still can't get real traction with someone intelligent like Victoria.
Only solution is to hand cuff Leonardo and Olivia together, lock them in a room, and let them figure it out. Left to their own devices, they will hesitate, second guess, dither and natter themselves into oblivion.
Great recap UA. As always, you get an A+ on your essay. And no points deducted for a very understandable and well deserved expletive.
Now, is Leonardo still thinking of the ultimate awkwardness of the morning he found Olivia tied up naked in her bed?
Or are both guys shying away from commitment and the risk of seeing their layloves with bleach in their hair and face cream on at night?
I totally agree with Niecie's characterization of the recap. ""wow" profound " is spot on and I couldn't have described it better, so I am stealing it. Wow profound indeed.
I especially loved the following lines:
"In our today's story Guilt is a tidalwave."
"Guilt is often the most useless emotion. It occasionally leads to solutions but often it leads down a very negative path."
"The guilty are meant to pay and some will pay a very high price"
I keep saying it in just about every other episode of this crap, but I am speechless how unprofessional and unethical Alejandra is!
Couple of episodes ago it was entering a motion against her own client on behalf of Daniela, ignoring an obvious conflict of interests and the fact that she owns her client a duty of loyalty, even though said client is a dumb and crazy beyotch.
And now, even worse, she is telling a defense lawyer not to defend his client to the best of his abilities:
"Jo espero que no impidas que este homber vaya a la carcel".- I hope you won't prevent this man from doing prison time.
"El merece una buena defense pero no la libertad, me oyes?"- He deserves a good defense, but not to be free, do you hear me.
Her demands are so unethical I can't believe the writers of this pile of manure (excuse me for my strong language, but this plot doesn't deserve better words) even put these words in the mouth of a protagonista. It's something a villain would say! What she basically says is the following: Carlos, I hope you interfere with justice so that this man goes to jail, you are free to defend him but don't do too good of a job, because I want him in jail.
In a somewhat functioning legal system, both Ale and Carlos would have been disbarred and publicly shamed if such a conversation would have become public.
And Carlos is committing an even worse ethics violation: he is defending both the father and the daughter, whose interests are opposite and he cannot provide good defense to one without sacrificing the defense of the other. In such situations, each defendant has to have his/her own lawyer, that will do his very best to protect his/ her interests!
And please, somebody, tell me why do the cops even exists in PASL universe (except to (badly) guard entrances to crime scenes) if they don't even investigate said crime scenes?! Carlos and Ale shouldn't have been there. It's up to the police to investigate and reconstruct crime scenes. And it's crazy that no one searched the house before and now Carlos has to tell the police how to do their job and search the house.
And don't they understand that whatever is found after Carlos and Ale visited the scene unaccompanied will be tainted and any lawyer with half-a-braincell will be able to claim that whatever is found was planted by Carlos and Ale?! Although, if Carlos is representing both defendants it doesn't really matter.
"I don't normally say this, but what the fuck? Did Leonardo feel guilty for wanting to be the man in Olivia's life? He may be the office nerd but isn't that better than a crook?"- I love it that the absurdity of this telenovela broke even the proper and prim Christopher Mason. Welcome to the club, my friend. My extra-strong titanium-plated beanie is yours if you want it. It won't save your brain from disintegrating, but it will dull the pain and will look really cool on you.
Irene
And what an angelic angel Elena turned out to be and what a great mother! That personality transplant really worked wonders on her. Can we now hope for a car crash for Olivia, Leo, Ale, Brick and Carlos?
Especially for Brick, who now displays signs of dementia by deciding to not to go ahead with the custody case and voluntarily laying in bed with Elena?
Irene
As eo Alejandra's issue of Octavio going to prison, I'm not sure what to think. Did Alejandra know him well enough to figure out whether the crime was committed in cold blood (If he had been the killer)? The best defense in this case could probably be temporary insanity (I think that is a thing in Mexican law) but that still wouldn't get him entirely off the hook.
Since we saw the crime I think we can all conclude that Nuria did this in cold blood but with inadequate forethought.
Of course, the lawyer has to represent the client to the best of his ability and keep his client's interests in mind, and that is often impossible under such circumstances, in which case it's the lawyer's duty to stop representing the client.
And in any case, to avoid being sued by the client afterwards, it's wise to politely explain the situation to the client and persuade him that it's in his best interest to find another lawyer.
It is possible that neither Brick nor Ale informed their clients about the conflict of interests. However, since the representation seemed to have concluded before the conflict of interests arose, they had no obligation to inform the clients about it.
But, when Daniela came to see Brick, of course Ale should have informed her client(Nuria) about the conflict of interests and Brick should have done the same with Daniela(although she did know that Ale now works in Vega, so was kind of aware of the conflict of interests).
However, the unethical decision not to inform the parties pales in comparison to what Alejandra did in acting on behalf of Daniela and against the interests of her own client. That's truly unethical, unprofessional and unacceptable. And worst of all, it was uncalled for, since any other lawyer could have helped Daniela.
Obviously, Alejandra had every right to stop representing Nuria, but for some reason she didn't do so (and by the way, it wouldn't have changed the fact that she is not allowed to represent Daniela).
As far as whether Octavio should be going to prison is concerned, this is not up to Alejandra to decide and it's certainly not appropriate for her to ask another lawyer to throw the case because she thinks that the defendant has to go to jail.
And a competent and ethical lawyer would certainly do all he can to spare Octavio jail by all means possible and I am sure an insanity defense would figure at the top of his list of possible lines of defense. Maybe nothing would have worked and the defendant would have been sentenced to 60 years in a maximum security prison, but at least the lawyer would have done his job, which is to defend his client to the best of his ability.
Irene
Irene
Say,I hate that Carlos is a guiltless jerk.
Such an attractive man this actor is.
They need to put him in A tn where's
He's A good guy. Carlos And ally work well together, but they made him a jerk. A Crook of a jerk. I want to see
How he handles this case tonight.
Letti still being Bitchy. She has no one to blame for her delimma but letti
She's not feelin guilty about nothin.
But she is blaming benny and he didnt
Cheat by himself.
Ricardo all around good guy feelin a
Bit of guilt. He shouldnt, but he does
I just hope he dont guilt himself into
A one sided lifeless marriage. Did
Y'all notice how deep fedfys voice is getting. They need to change his way
Of acting. He is not a little kid. He
Is still crawlin into mommies bed and
Laying on her crying. Most 13 yr olds
Wouldnt be caught dead doing that nowa
Days. What a mess. Ricardo good luck
Baby. You're gonna need it. And that
Look on elena's face, "he's baaaaack".
Lonny Is really down in the mouth. He
Will be ok, he's got his honey by his
Side. He better watch his back the D
Brothers are in a bad mood.
I know Susanna loves her son but they
Need some space. That tiny apartment is........tiny. Maybe if we say that
Enough the writers will do Something.
If they even read our comments.
Robby need to be ashame of himself and
Dragging Leo into his dating games with these bobble head silly women. He
Is not that hard up. Unless he is just lookin for somebody to have escapades with And that's probably it. Thats not
Healthy. Be careful Vicky.
Thank you Urban.
Most of these characters need shrinks.
Julian Gil always seems to be cast as a villain because he has the eyes for it. I don't find him attractive at all.
I usually DO say, "what the fuck?" Maybe it's my inability to deal with stupid people and their doings.
Now we have a whole troop of incompetent lawyers and detectives, including Carlos and Ale.
I remember that US soap operas had doctors, lawyers, etc. advise them regarding the validity of their scripts.
Why, (WTF!) can't telenovelas have the same expertise at their fingertips. Too many beanie hats in the last few years of novela programing.
ANON: At least UNI is only airing one more reason of El Chapo (I don't like narcos) and not endless episodes like Señor de los Cielos!
Urban,
I love Christopher Mason; I loved watching him and Robert Stack in Unsolved Mysteries.
PASL at least gave Julian Gil's villain more depth than his past villains. I have enjoyed watching him here and he wears a suit well.
I hope we get Me Declaro Culpable soon. I'd like to see if Mexican TNs in general could care less about realism in law and courts, or if it's just PASL. But then, PASL is a remake of a Colombian TN, so maybe the loco law scenarios here began in Colombia.
The announcer guy said this novela would be over on July 6 (Next Friday).
I completely agree that both QBA an VEA should have had lots more English in them.
<< Home
© Caray, Caray! 2006-2022. Duplication of this material for use on any other site is strictly prohibited.