Friday, January 10, 2014
Weekend Discussion: Culture Shock
I'd love to know whether men and women still interact as though it were the Victorian age. Mexican women go to college and have careers; shouldn't that have eliminated the ridiculous notion that they exist only for their men and their children? Despite it being a comedy, the sexism in Por Ella Soy Eva really was disturbing. Do Mexican fathers really devalue their daughters like that?
Do parents really call their children "princesa," "mi reina", "mi rey," etc.? This really bugs me because I can't help thinking that this is more appropriate for a significant other. I can't help thinking that applying this to a child is spoiling them and giving them a sense of entitlement.
Sound off, amigos.
Labels: por-ella, telenovelas, weekend
Second thing that always seems strange to me is the value that is placed on certain family names. Like some chica gets pregnant and guys are offering to marry her so her baby can have a name. Can't she just give the baby her last name? What's wrong with that? Or the rich people obsessing over who does or does not carry their family name or acting like having that name automatically makes them better than other people. Or, again with Sebastard, he worries that because he was adopted and not a biokid that he will have the family last name taken away from him. Can they even do that? It's his legal name.
As for whether a legal name can be revoked, I don't know. It gets done in the 1993 Corazon Salvaje but I don't know that it can be done now.
The DNA thing mystifies me, too, but I have a good friend who still cries about how her genetic family doesn't love her. She comes from a very toxic family and also knows that this is not her fault, nor is it anything unusual. She's read as many books on this as I have but seems to take no comfort from the ability to create your own family out of your friends. It's not logical, but it happens.
I wonder why this is why we see so many characters who are adopted go to adulthood without knowing this.
I have no idea what the norm is anywhere else in the world, but the current conventional wisdom about adoption in the US is to tell the child as soon as s/he is old enough to understand. I don't know if that's right, either, but there are many compelling reasons for them to ultimately know.
I know next to nothing about the Latin Culture but----Why would anyone object to calling your daughter princess or princesa?
Little girls are beautiful and sweet, if I had one, I would love to call her precious, princess, princesa or something to that affect. What's wrong with that? Little girls are only little for a short time, what is wrong with letting them know that you love them and that you think of them as a princess?
the gringo
There is nothing wrong with telling your child you love him/her. More parents should do that (if they mean it). However, there is a line between that and spoiling.
One of my mother's cousins uses princesa for her daughter but I can't remember anyone else using it. It's definitely less common. mi reina/mi rey are very common and not just for children but some people even use them for strangers, that use of the nickname is seen as low class by some.
And yeah, sexism is alive and well in Mexico. Very much. Men like Fernando in PESE are out there everywhere.
Julia:
About the last names, I do think the novelas exaggerate this. However, since all children carry both the last name of their father and the last name of their mother, a child with just one last name would be very noticeable. At school both of our last names get called during roll call and at every place you get registered (schools, clubs, work, etc.) both of the last names are required. Some people do ask for your second last name when you meet them, since they like to guess if you have some relation to someone they might know.
Jarocha
Your parents are supposed make you feel special to them and then you go into the real world.
I call my children honey and sweetie. Yes, I live in San Diego, Mexican Americans refer to their children that way as well and I think its beautiful.
My friend is African-English and she treats her like princes and princesses as well. Her kids are well adjusted. Somebody's gotta make them feel good...cuz no one else will.
Cynderella
My culture shocks would be things like Salomon Ladino and the stereotyping I sometimes see, but I remind myself that there are cultural differences.
I cannot recall any female characters referring to their husbands as "viejos."
In the US teens frequently refer to their parents in this way, but usually as a way of indicating they are in some position of authority. Not always offensively, but it's something they should stop if their parents really hate it.
Then I learned more about religion in general and it didn't surprise me so much anymore.Or maybe I just got used to it?
We have more atheists here than religious people and we arent really taught about religion in school or anywhere.So its more what we learn from TV and the internet.
I don't see anything wrong with calling children endearments...Your parents are supposed to make you feel special to them and then you go into the real world.
Cynderella, I so agree. My parents used to call me what I realize now are some very non-PC endearments (wow, just realized they would've sounded so cool in Spanish!). But it's the feeling of love, affection, and appreciation that I remember most.
I get that outsiders can find these endearments annoying, but I like hearing "mi solecito" and "mi luna de miel."
From Jarocha's comment about sexism Mexico, I guess that is why for me the sexism in comedies like PESE or PEAM isn't all that funny. And because its stretched out over many weeks, it just seems to continue a really bad joke.
As people seem to become more heartless in our society, I think parents need to continue to make their children feel special and if those terms do that, then keep at it.
My maternal grandmother lived with us and always made me feel loved, protected, and very special. Even though she died when I was eleven, that feeling of being loved has gotten me through some very bad times in my life. She called me "my little Susan.,,
When I first started watching novelas, one of the fascinating aspects was hearing the galan call his Onetruelove Mi Amor, Mi Cielo, Mi Vida.
The issue I have is this whole Princess Culture thing that is running rampant among American little girl society. I don't know how prevalent this is in other countries. But there's this whole promotion of princessiness that incorporates a lot of artificial and unnecessary gender norming, pinkification of any and every product which girls are told is what they should want, promotion of stereotypes to the point that girls are discouraged from adventurous and brainy pursuits and steered toward the frivolous. Plus the way the sort of people who promote that agenda also tend to embrace an anti-feminist backlash and to limit the roles of women.
It seems so backward and anachronistic, but it's an attitude that is alive and well, and the training starts by teaching little girls that they are princessy; that their role is to be pretty and supportive and to revolve around the boys who do the big stuff. Because being a pretty princess and being taken care of is the ultimate; forget having power of your own or choosing your role in life based on your personality. They're being given second class status and made to believe that it is a prize they have won.
So maybe, probably, that isn't what parents intend to connote when they call their daughters "princesa" in a sugary way, but that is what I hear.
What I see in stores and Facebook posts by parents of some girls kind of alarms me, though. It's so much SATURATION of pink and putting importance on prettiness and pushing kids into one activity vs. another and telling them that navy blue is a boy color and fashion is a girl hobby and then women are posting all this stuff about how "worldly women" just don't understand how special women are, and don't they know that they would be happier if they just played second fiddle to some handsome prince who could take care of all the hard stuff for them, oh and also it is girls' job to be attractive for boys but not too attractive because they are also responsible for managing boys' hormones, and it just makes me want to scream.
Clearly I just need to filter my communication spheres more carefully. If only I could hang out on the POLE all the time in real life! Fewer aggravations, and the ones there are exist onscreen and can be dealt with by a therapeutic onslaught of Nerfazos.
I can see how it would be a sensitive issue to not have two family names if all the other kids do and they are both used for classes and forms and whatnot.
In the U.S., parents can give their children whatever surname they want. It can be either of the parents' last names, or both, or something else entirely. If the father bails, the mother can still choose to list him as the father on the birth certificate and to give the child his last name if she wants to. He doesn't have to give permission. Is this not allowed or just not done in Mexico?
I did know a man with only one last name but he alwats joked about it saying that the secretary forgot to add it in his birth certificate. Now I don't know if that's true or not.
Jarocha
So maybe, probably, that isn't what parents intend to connote when they call their daughters "princesa" in a sugary way, but that is what I hear.
I completely agree with this.
When my college buddy's first daughter was born I begged him not to let his daughters become sissified. This is so bad for girls and the women they should become in the 21st century. Somehow, though, his younger daughter seemed to develop a sense of entitlement when she was about 8 or so, actually asking me what I paid for a gift I gave her for Christmas. They lived in an affluent area where new cars and designer clothes decided who was who, but I don't regard that as an excuse.
For reasons having nothing to do with that specific situation, that was the last gift I ever gave her.
What strikes me in the telenovelas I’ve seen is this:
In our romantic movies, when the couple marries at the end, they take off in their Just Married car with the tin cans rattling behind them, heading for the horizon where their future lies. Bye!
In the novelas, (and this is what I find so endearing about them) the stated goal throughout is to be together – not just the two lovers, but everybody. Grannies, faithful servants, siblings, parents, a huge circle of friends, kids, babies, the dog. We end up with the boda, everybody present. Confetti! Group hug! The couple doesn’t go anywhere because they are where they want to be.
Every once and a while I see a mature couple who have grown so much into each other that they look alike. They stop having the separate identities that drew them to each other and start looking like brother and sister. I find that scary and I think that is one of the things that can create a Gaby (PSMA).
I think the only time the princesa thing bothered me was in PEAM, because Jesus (FC) used it ALL the time with his little daughter. It was constant, sugary, and grating. He hardly ever used her real name or any other term of endearment. AND he went out of his way to create a whole princess lifestyle and mythology around her. It was grating.
But I loved what her other dad called her, chaparrita. That was cute.
I love that some cultures in the US (like the South), and Latin America use terms of endearment so liberally. You have to be raised with it to make it roll easily off the tongue.
Urban- I recorded the final week of Privilegio de Amar and am just now watching it. Just watched Cynthia Klitbo shave her head. Wow! She has guts.
Sue in Miami
In her case her parents did a very positive thing.
Sue in Miami
Let me know what you think of the Karmageddons in the finale.
There have been other actresses shaving their heads for roles in films but I can't remember any other else doing it for a telenovela. Actors have done it but it's not the same.
Jarocha
Urban- I enjoyed the villains' ends in this so much better than in Triunfo, where the bad guys really did not face the consequences of their actions and had easy/quick deaths. I really don't know why Mejia bothered to remake it. All in all, it was a MUCH better tn than Tirunfo.
As for Ana Joaquina's, I felt very bad for Padre Juan because I knew he would never give up on her and until she finally died he would still hold out hopes for her redemption. However, her arrogance in even boasting to the police about being appointed to enact God's vengeance was the big telling factor that she was irredeemable.
Condensed DVDs always leave out the great confrontations that we look forward to. This series had lots of really good ones.
<< Home
© Caray, Caray! 2006-2022. Duplication of this material for use on any other site is strictly prohibited.